Jeff,
just so you know I stared at my comment for a few seconds longer then usual and noted its inflammatory non productive nature. I really should have deleted it but it was after all a rant in which without the…rest of the story…one really could not understand my feelings on the matter and most importantly how the issue of our safety and the safety of those we in our delegated authorization are responsible for.
For example, last summer some one with one of those new little jets had an alternator out and asked me if I could replace it. I told him I did not have the recency of experience to sign of the replacement and also did not feel i had any business touching his shinny new oil burning toy even though in another life I had been checked out in the heavies up to the triple seven. That being said another mechanic with much less experience, and in my opinion not enough to wipe the wet from behind his ears, replaced the alternator for him.
I guess my point is that when another A&P comes into my shop to ask about something he has absolutely no business touching without a good year of OJT or at least a fancy piece of paper saying he is aproved, then he should have enough sense to recommend the repair to the qualified.
I must admit i am slowly turning into one of those crotchety anal retentive A&Ps you find at any(every) dirt strip wooden hanger. You know the one that makes you redo the safety wire over and over and over again until it looks perfect or wet sand that dollar patch one more time but at the same time he shares his tools and shop and time…and perhaps most importantly his love of aviation.
Just so you know I went over to help out the above mentioned mechanic…against my better judgment.
Rocket